It’s Me or the Dog

By H.J. Harley, author of Finding Jordie

Finding JordieFor ten years you’ve come home to Sparky, your loyal best friend since you were twelve. Without fail he’s waiting at the door when you come home with a wagging tail and big fat lick on the face, and that’s how it’s always been. You and Sparky, BFF. Sure, you’ve had boyfriends, but nothing that ever turned into anything serious, and at the end of the day there was Sparky with his unwavering affection.

Then it happens. You meet him. The man of your dreams. Date after date, it just gets better and better. You invite him to your place for a romantic tenth date. He shows up promptly at 7pm, flowers in hand, looking like Prince Charming, with an actual *ding* and all when he smiles. When you show him in, he kisses your cheek while handing you the flowers. As he takes that first step in, Sparky comes full speed around the corner and jumps up on ol’ Prince Charming and he immediately cowers back in disgust.

Oh no. He isn’t a dog person.

How could you have overlooked such an important detail? How did this never come up? You never mentioned old Sparky?? And just like that you realize you have a huge decision to make. Your past or your future? Who doesn’t like dogs!? Prince Charming, that’s who, and while putting Sparky in the spare bedroom for the evening will be a quick fix, what does this mean in the long run? Can you chose between your bestest and most loyal friend for over a decade and the guy that makes you warm and fuzzy all over?

I got lucky. My Prince Charming happened to have two dogs and a cat of his own when we met, so bringing my three cats into the mix was a cake walk. But I wonder sometimes what would’ve happened if he hadn’t been so accepting of my furry kids. Well, for me it’s pretty simple… They were here first. Love me, love my animals. But for some it isn’t that cut and dried. So the next step would be to figure out why exactly your mate doesn’t like domestic animals. Are they allergic? Does the thought of having to meticulously lint roll your clothing every ten minutes annoy them? Perhaps their favorite teddy bear was chewed up and violated by a poodle. Whatever the case is, you need to figure out why and see if there is any chance for a compromise in the situation, because if not, what it comes down to is, “It’s me or the dog.” And that just doesn’t work for me.

Have you ever had to choose between your furry kids and the man (or woman) of your dreams? Share your stories in the comments!

8 thoughts on “It’s Me or the Dog

  1. Great post, HJ! When I met my Prince Charming, neither of us had pets due to apartment restrictions, but after we got married and had our own home I found a Siamese cat at our local shelter. I’d had a Siamese when I was growing up and wanted to adopt this little sweetie. My husband kind of hemmed and hawed, though, and said he’d dated a girl in high school who had a Siamese that absolutely hated him. Every time he went to her house the cat would jump on his head! After assuring him I wouldn’t let mayhem commence with this shelter cat, we adopted him. Of course, the cat ended up loving my husband and vice versa. He was with us for nineteen years, and I’m so grateful I didn’t have to choose between my Prince Charming and my Siamese cat!

  2. Oh, deal breaker! People who love animals make the best boyfriends/girlfriends/spouses. The patience and love required to be a pet owner is definitely transferable to the love of a person. Granted, my husband will not piddle on the floor, but when our dog does, it makes the husband’s habit of leaving socks in our bed that much less offensive ;)

  3. Been there, done that! I figure any man who is so threatened by a few pet hairs wasn’t really worthy of my time, and ultimatums really don’t work in relationships. Turns out I married a man who is technically allergic to cats! (I had four when we met, and one I always pet-sat.) The right man puts his love first, and I am very lucky that my Prince Charming really does love animals. Love me, love my hairballs…. or something like that…..

  4. Love the post, HJ. I was a married woman, already, but we turned down a home in a subdivision that wouldn’t have allowed us to keep our rottweiler. A partner who doesn’t like animals…just don’t think that would have worked for me! And I like tevinmyst’s post above–the right partner puts love first!

Leave a Reply